Public Authorities 'Flatly Refute' HRW's Attempt to Give Impression of Lack of Independence of Moroccan Justice

Public Authorities 'Flatly Refute' HRW's Attempt to Give Impression of Lack of Independence of Moroccan Justice
Wednesday 30 September 2020 - 20:50

Public authorities flatly refuted, on Wednesday, the “tendentious” publication by Human Rights Watch entitled “Morocco: a critical journalist prosecuted for spying”, dated Sept. 21, 2020 , through which the organization tries to mislead the public opinion by giving the impression that the national judicial system is not independent.

In a statement, the public authorities affirm that the judiciary is independent under the Constitution and that the implementation of guarantees of the independence of magistrates falls under the prerogatives of the Higher Council of the Judiciary, a special constitutional institution, independent from the executive and legislative powers. 

This institution had published, on September 15, 2020, a press release defending the independence and inviolability of the judiciary, in response to certain international NGOs which, instead of contributing to the consolidation of this independence, are calling for putting pressure to undermine it, the same source recalled.

The Moroccan justice is the only party responsible for the case of the person concerned, prosecuted for his alleged involvement in the perpetration of acts incriminated by the Moroccan criminal law, the public authorities insisted. These are acts punishable by legal measures and procedures that meet the requirements of a fair trial, the same source said.

This legal action is in no way linked to the exercise by the person concerned of his job as a journalist. Only the Moroccan Press and Publishing Code is entitled to govern the latter’s articles and investigations, knowing that the capacity of journalist does not exempt the person from legal proceedings, if the charges brought against the defendant constitute material and moral legal elements of a crime which falls under the public law, the statement explained.

The public authorities categorically reject HRW’s repeated attempts to take on roles unrelated to the defense of human rights, as in its latest publication which attempted to cast doubt on judgments, to exploit, in bad faith, the confidentiality of judicial investigations, and to influence the normal course of a judicial case which is at its very beginning.

The Organization tried to present an image contrary to the case’s ins and outs and misinterpreted legal and judicial texts and procedures without providing tangible legal or material evidence on the non-veracity of the criminal acts stated in the said case, an action that only the judiciary are entitled to take in all legal systems, the statement said.

The false conclusions and pre-judgments contained in the publication can only reflect methodological bases which are devoid of objectivity and marred with selectivity, an approach which is specific to the organization in dealing with the human rights situation in Morocco, the statement added.

The authorities are surprised by HRW’s denial of the right to freedom of expression and opinion to some national media outlets over the only reason of publishing articles which are not necessarily in harmony with the conclusions of the organization and the directives of its supporting parties, the same source noted.

In addition, the organization adopted a single-party versions as is the case concerning the suspected rape and indecent assault, since the organization violated the right of the person concerned to judicial protection. Worse still, it has deliberately denied her professional capacity, a fact also noted by the National Union of the Moroccan Press in its press release of September 24, 2020, it concluded.

add your comment

Terms of publication : Not to offend the writer, people, sacred things, or attack religions or the divine self, and refrain from racist incitement and insults.

News
Dutch lawmakers challenge Google over racist search suggestions targeting Moroccans
Wednesday 18 November 2026 - 20:00

Dutch lawmakers challenge Google over racist search suggestions targeting Moroccans

Economy
Morocco’s GDP per capita set to exceed $5,000 for first time in 2026, IMF forecasts
Wednesday 18 November 2026 - 18:00

Morocco’s GDP per capita set to exceed $5,000 for first time in 2026, IMF forecasts

News
Morocco, UAE sign security cooperation agreement to strengthen intelligence sharing
Wednesday 18 November 2026 - 14:20

Morocco, UAE sign security cooperation agreement to strengthen intelligence sharing

Culture
FIFM removes Palestinian-Syrian director’s film from competition at Algerian 'producer’s request'
Wednesday 18 November 2026 - 13:20

FIFM removes Palestinian-Syrian director’s film from competition at Algerian 'producer’s request'