Spanish court rejects buyers’ bid to recover €201,000 for unfinished Morocco property

Spanish court rejects buyers’ bid to recover €201,000 for unfinished Morocco property
Sunday 22 November 2026 - 13:16

A regional appeals court in Madrid has rejected a claim seeking to compel two Spanish banks to refund more than €201,000 paid by buyers for a home under construction in Morocco’s Saidia, ruling that the transaction was governed by Moroccan law and was not covered by Spanish legal protections for buyers of off-plan properties.

In a decision issued on October 20, 2026, the Madrid Provincial Court upheld an earlier judgment dismissing the claim against the two financial institutions. The buyers had sought to recover €201,327.55 paid toward the purchase of a property that was never completed or handed over.

The court found that the use of a Spanish bank account to receive the payments was not sufficient to make the banks liable for the failure to complete the project. It pointed to the property’s location in Morocco, the Moroccan developer and a contractual clause assigning disputes to courts in Oujda.

The ruling ends, at this stage of the proceedings, the buyers’ attempt to recover their money from the Spanish banks. It does not, however, determine the contractual liability of the developer responsible for building and delivering the property.

Dispute over payments for unfinished home

The case stems from an agreement to purchase a home in a real estate development in Saidia, signed by a buyer holding Spanish and British citizenship and residing in the United Kingdom, together with a Moroccan property development company headquartered in Oujda.

The buyers made advance payments totaling €201,327.55 through a bank account in Spain. However, construction was not completed and the agreed property was never delivered.

After the project stalled, the buyers sought reimbursement from the two Spanish banks, arguing that financial institutions receiving payments for properties under construction could incur legal liability if they failed to ensure that the required safeguards were in place to protect buyers’ funds.

Their claim relied on Spain’s Law 57/1968, which established protections for advance payments made by buyers of homes under construction. Under certain circumstances, the law can impose obligations on banks that receive such payments without the legally required guarantees.

The buyers argued that the banks should have checked the nature of the funds deposited into the developer’s account and ensured that safeguards were in place to allow the money to be recovered if construction was not completed or contractual delivery obligations were breached.

Madrid’s Court of First Instance No. 38 dismissed the claim in a judgment issued on March 31, 2025. It found that the documents submitted did not establish that the banks were involved in financing or managing the Moroccan project, or that they knew the contractual details underlying each transfer.

The first-instance court also pointed to indications that the property purchase may have been investment-related, while the protections invoked by the buyers were primarily intended for homes acquired for personal use. This was among the grounds considered in dismissing the claim.

Court finds Moroccan law applicable

During the appeal, the buyers maintained that depositing the money with Spanish financial institutions triggered obligations under Spanish legislation protecting purchasers of properties under construction.

The banks argued that the sale agreement was governed by Moroccan law and that they could not be held liable under Spanish safeguards that did not apply to the transaction.

The appeals court sided with the banks, citing the property’s location in Saidia, the Moroccan nationality of the developer and the fact that the contract was concluded in Oujda. The agreement did not expressly stipulate that Spanish law would apply.

The contractual jurisdiction clause also featured in the court’s reasoning. It assigned potential disputes arising from the agreement to the courts of Oujda, reinforcing the transaction’s connection to the Moroccan legal system.

The judges further noted that the parties did not share a common nationality or habitual residence that would establish a legal connection justifying the application of Spanish legislation. The fact that payments passed through a Spanish bank account was not, in the court’s assessment, sufficient to change the law governing the property transaction.

The proceedings also addressed the relationship between the Moroccan developer and a Spanish investment group associated with it. However, the existence of that connection was not considered sufficient to establish the two banks’ liability for the money paid, according to the first-instance court’s reasoning.

The appeals court concluded that because the contract was governed by Moroccan law, the protections provided under Spain’s Law 57/1968 could not be applied to the transaction. The banks therefore could not be held to obligations arising from legislation that did not govern the property purchase.

The decision highlights a legal consideration in cross-border real estate disputes: using a bank account in one country to pay for a property located in another does not automatically bring the transaction under the buyer-protection rules of the country where the account is held. The contractual terms and the transaction’s links to the relevant legal systems remain important in determining the applicable law.

Limitation period and legal costs

The dispute also involved the question of whether the claim had been filed within the applicable limitation period. One of the banks argued that the buyers had initiated proceedings after the legal deadline for pursuing their claims had expired.

According to the case documents, the buyers sent an out-of-court demand to the bank on February 12, 2021, before filing their lawsuit on March 30, 2022. The limitation issue was examined under provisions of the Spanish Civil Code and relevant Supreme Court case law.

The appeals court upheld the limitation defense as part of its reasoning, alongside its principal finding that Spanish legislation did not apply to the property purchase in Saidia.

The court issued its decision on October 20, 2026, without holding an additional public hearing, finding that the documents and arguments submitted were sufficient to decide the appeal.

It upheld the first-instance judgment dismissing the claim, ordered the buyers to pay the costs of the appeal proceedings and ruled that they would forfeit the amount deposited as security for the appeal.

add your comment

Terms of publication : Not to offend the writer, people, sacred things, or attack religions or the divine self, and refrain from racist incitement and insults.

Politics
MINURSO withdrawal could raise risk of wider Morocco-Algeria conflict, crisis group warns
Sunday 22 November 2026 - 12:30

MINURSO withdrawal could raise risk of wider Morocco-Algeria conflict, crisis group warns

Economy
Morocco’s currency market faces renewed pressure as dollar demand outpaces supply
Sunday 22 November 2026 - 10:00

Morocco’s currency market faces renewed pressure as dollar demand outpaces supply

Culture
Prince Moulay Rachid preside over royal dinner at Marrakech Film Festival
Saturday 21 November 2026 - 23:34

Prince Moulay Rachid preside over royal dinner at Marrakech Film Festival

Sports
Morocco vs Ghana: When and where to watch the Amputee Football World Cup final
Saturday 21 November 2026 - 23:02

Morocco vs Ghana: When and where to watch the Amputee Football World Cup final