Scholars: Eid al-Adha spirit endures despite sacrifice suspension

Muslim scholars and religious experts have welcomed King Mohammed VI’s recent directive to suspend the ritual sacrifice for Eid al-Adha, calling it a legitimate and compassionate decision rooted in Islamic principles that prioritize mercy, flexibility and the public good.

The royal measure, prompted by current economic and environmental challenges, was widely praised as a response to the financial strain facing Moroccan households and the need to protect the nation’s livestock.

While the ritual of animal sacrifice remains a revered Eid tradition, scholars emphasized it is not mandatory during times of hardship.

“The royal message to suspend the Eid sacrifice reflects the flexibility of Sharia and its emphasis on easing hardship and promoting the common good,” said Mohsen Al-Yermani, a researcher in Islamic thought and comparative religion. “It preserves livestock for food security and offers relief to families burdened by the high cost of sacrificial animals.”

Al-Yermani said the core meaning of Eid lies not in the act of slaughter, but in devotion, gratitude and compassion. He noted that Islamic teachings include various Eid practices, such as prayer, charity and strengthening family bonds.

Mohammed Labiti, a preacher and scholar of Islamic jurisprudence, underscored that suspending the sacrifice does not diminish the religious significance of Eid al-Adha.

“Eid remains a central pillar of Islamic life. What has been suspended is a single ritual, not the holiday itself,” he told Hespress.

Labiti said the decision falls within the bounds of ijtihad, or legal reasoning, particularly when exercised by the King in his role as Commander of the Faithful and head of the Supreme Council of Ulema.

“The Prophet Muhammad taught that if a ruler makes ijtihad and is correct, he earns two rewards; if mistaken, he still earns one,” Labiti said. “This shows that religious interpretation is dynamic and responsive to real-life conditions.”

He urged Moroccans to observe Eid with sincerity and solidarity. “Whether or not the sacrifice is performed, the values of faith, unity and compassion should remain at the heart of the celebration,” he said.