Israel’s National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich’s endorsement of Palestinian voluntary migration and Gaza Strip settlement rebuilding has garnered significant global criticism.
Zionism and Otzma Yehudit party leaders proposed that as a permanent solution to the long conflict, which in their view would ensure stability and allow southern Israeli residents to return to their homes.
The United States, according to an immediate release, denounced the controversial remarks made by the two Israeli Ministers, describing their rhetoric as “inflammatory and irresponsible.”
The Israeli government, including the Prime Minister, has consistently stated that such statements do not align with their policy and should be immediately halted, highlighted in the release.
“We have been clear, consistent, and unequivocal that Gaza is Palestinian land and will remain Palestinian land,” underscored the same source.
Matthew Miller, US Department Spokesperson, took to X (formerly known as Twitter) and said, “There should be no mass displacement of Palestinians from Gaza.”
Linda Thomas, US Ambassador to the UN who previously blocked a motion to condemn violence against civilians in Gaza on October 18th, also joined Miller’s call for no mass displacement of Palestinians, describing the two Israeli far-right leaders’ statement as inflammatory.
In response to the US’s reaction, Ben Gabir said on X, “The United States is our dear friend, but first, we will do what is best for the State of Israel: emigrate hundreds of thousands of Gaza will allow the residents of the Gaza Strip settlements to return to their homes and live in safety and will protect IDF soldiers.”
Israel’s Finance Minister Smotrich highlighted that “More than 70% of the Israeli public today supports a humanitarian solution of encouraging the voluntary immigration of Gaza Arabs and their absorption in other countries.”
He added that they “are required to rethink and share with friends in the international community that will bring peace, security, and prosperity to all the peoples of the region and allow the residents of the south to return to their homes in safety and peace.”
Israeli Minister of Intelligence Gila Gamliel previously stated that voluntary migration is the most realistic and effective program for the day after the end of the fighting, reported Zman, according to The Times of Israel.
France joined the US and openly denounced the mass displacement of Gazans from their homeland.
“France is opposed to the forced displacement of populations. That’s very clear-cut…We will not support the forced displacement of people,” said Nicolas de Riviere, the permanent representative of France to the UN, on Tuesday to reporters.
De Riviere emphasized the importance of Palestinians living peacefully in their homes, putting an end to indiscriminate bombings targeting civilians in Gaza, and refraining from damaging hospitals and schools.
On its part, the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs also criticized the statements made by the two Israeli Ministers, describing them as irresponsible.
“The Netherlands rejects any calls for Palestinian displacement from Gaza or reduction of Palestinian territory,” posted on X, stressing that their remarks do not align with the two-state solution.
The Spanish Ministry of Foreign Affairs also rejects the two Israeli Ministers’ suggestion, saying that forcible tranfer “would be contrary to international law.”
Josep Borrell Fontelles, Vice-President of the European Commission, also denounced those statements, which are in his view “irresponsible and inflammatory.
“Forced displacements are strictly prohibited as a grave violation of IHL & words matter,” said on X.
UN Special Rapporteur on the right to housing described on X the forcible transfer of the Gazan population as an act of genocide. “Congolese or other States officials will be guilty of aiding and abetting genocide if they agree to any transfer of population.”
Joaquín Castro, a member of the Democratic Party, representing Texas in the United States House of Representatives, said, “Itamar Ben-Gvir, the Minister of National Security in Benjamin Netanyahu’s cabinet, was previously convicted of supporting a terrorist organization. Now, he is advocating for ethnic cleansing in Gaza.”
Francesca Albanese, The UN Special Rapporteur on the occupied Palestinian territories, said, “Forced displacement is a crime against humanity. Israel has been perpetrating that with impunity during decades of illegal occupation.”
Ahmad Tibi, an Arab Knesset member, reacted to the two Israrli Ministers’ remarks, calling them “a war crime.” He added, “A day will come when you will be held accountable for your crimes against humanity.”
He emphasized that such rhetoric incites genocide.
Kenneth Roth, a former executive director of Human Rights Watch, wrote about the US opposition to those controversial remarks, and questioned, “will there be consequences if Netanyahu proceeds nonetheless? There have been no consequences for his bombing and besieging war crimes.”
“We condemn Israeli Minister Smotrich’s call for ethnic cleansing. Along with most major American Jewish leaders, we have refused to meet with him to sanction his politics and beliefs,” said Rabbi Rick Jacobs, President of the Union for Reform Judaism, the largest Jewish movement in North America.
Netanyahu’s office has denied that Smotrich and Ben Gvir represent government policy on population transfer, despite its recent support for the matter, according to the Times of Israel.
It also reported that Israel is in discussions with various nations about the possibility of absorbing Palestinians from Gaza through voluntary resettlement.
“Zman Israel, The Times of Israel’s Hebrew sister site, has learned that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s coalition is conducting secret contacts for accepting thousands of immigrants from Gaza with Congo, in addition to other nations,” added the same source.
Netanyahu stated at a Likud faction meeting that he is working to facilitate the voluntary migration of Gazans to other countries, addressing the problem of finding countries to absorb Gazans.
Under the 4th article of the Geneva Convention, “Individual or mass forcible transfers…are prohibited, regardless of their motive.”
According to the International Criminal Court (ICC), forceful displacement of civilians is also a war crime unless justified by “military necessity” or civilian protection.
By 2023, nearly 2 million people, or 85% of Gaza’s population, were internally displaced, with 1.4 million in 155 UNRWA facilities. Rafah governorate is the main refuge, with over one million people in overcrowded conditions.
add your comment
Terms of publication : Not to offend the writer, people, sacred things, or attack religions or the divine self, and refrain from racist incitement and insults.