Morocco’s defamation lawsuits against French Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) and media outlets that denounced Rabat’s alleged use of the Pegasus spying software were announced inadmissible on Friday, March 25, by French justice.
The Kingdom was accused in July 2021 of using the computer program Pegasus designed by the Israeli company NSO.
Morocco deemed the accusations as “False and unfounded allegations.”
The Paris Correctional Court has issued ten rulings declaring the direct summonses against France Media Monde, L’Humanité, Le Monde, Radio France, Mediapart, Forbidden Stories, and Amnesty International inadmissible.
Morocco has previously undertaken several legal proceedings against these accusations in France, Spain, and Germany.
The French court’s rulings are based on an article of the French 1881 law on freedom of the press that “Does not allow a state, which cannot be assimilated to a private individual within the meaning of this text, to sue for defamation.”
Lawyer Simon Foreman of Amnesty International welcomed the court’s ruling, commenting that “It was not unexpected, the case law was very much along these lines.”
The prosecutor had asked the court to apply a “Constant” jurisprudence of the Court of Cassation, which states that “A state, whether French or foreign,” cannot sue for defamation. “It is a fundamental requirement of freedom of expression to be able to criticize a state, which has other means to defend itself,” it added.
During the trial, the organizations’ lawyers and media have asked for the inadmissibility of this “gag procedure,” as they described it.
For his part, Le Monde’s lawyer, Christophe Bigot, described the decision as “Being in line with usual practice when it comes to actions taken by a state and which allow for the preservation of freedom of criticism against a country.”
Olivier Baratelli and Rodolphe Bosselut, lawyers of Morocco, declared that “Morocco, by immediately appealing the judgment, renews its confidence in French justice and relies on the Court of Appeal of Paris that will say that Amnesty and Forbidden Stories have played the sorcerer’s apprentice by publishing false information and disseminating a fable unverified.”
In this case, Morocco can move the case to appeal, as expressed by the Kingdom’s lawyer, arguing that their request was admissible because it is not the State, but an administration, which attacks in defamation.
Similarly, as for other countries, Morocco was accused of using Pegasus following an alleged investigation of 17 international media outlets based on data obtained by the Organizations Forbidden Stories and Amnesty International.
Note that the claims of abuse of process formulated by these media agencies and NGOs were also rejected.
Based on the Pegasus revelations, an investigation was opened on July 20 by the Paris public prosecutor’s office.
Once installed in a cell phone, Pegasus software allows spying on the user of the device, accessing their messaging and data, and activating the device remotely to capture sound or image.
Human rights organizations and Moroccan media professionals have previously asked the presidents of the two chambers of the Parliament of Morocco to investigate the scandal of Pegasus used to see if Morocco spied on local and foreign public figures.
add your comment
Terms of publication : Not to offend the writer, people, sacred things, or attack religions or the divine self, and refrain from racist incitement and insults.