Casablanca’s court of first instance on Monday delivered its verdict in the defamation lawsuit filed by the Director General of the Moroccan News Agency (MAP), Khalil Hachimi Idrissi, against the journalist Abdellah Bakkali.
The Court sentenced to a fine the editor of the newspaper “Assabah”, Abdelmounaim Dilami, as well as Mokhtar Ramchi, author of the offending article, who reported the defamatory remarks of Abdellah Bakkali, which the latter denied before the judge.
Acquitted on the basis of the abjuration of his own words, Bakkali thus shows the inability to accept his own statements or issue a denial, which could end the entire legal process against him.
By this attitude, to say the least irresponsible, Bakkali left the journalist of the daily “Assabah” and the director of the publication to face alone a lawsuit which does not concern them directly.
He thus brought on trial a member of the National Press Council (CNP) where he himself sits and created a dangerous precedent in the profession, which is in flagrant violation of ethical rules, which he continues to plead for as an irremovable president of the National Trade Union of the Moroccan Press.
In this regard, Hachimi Idrissi’s lawyer, Abdelali El Quessar, said that serious accusations made against the Director General of the MAP and published in an article by the newspaper “Assabah” were attributed to Abdellah Bakkali, who did not react.
“We must not ignore this attitude: Abdellah Bakkali should have made a denial a very long time ago before the judge when the case was under examination”, El Quessar told MAP.
Noting that the judge said that there is no text that requires Abdellah Bakkali to issue a denial to the newspaper, the lawyer said that of course, there is no text in this direction, but the criminal act of insult and defamation exists by broadcasting.
“So the press offense was committed. This is the materiality of the offense”, he said, considering that the judgment pronounced by the court is an astonishing reversal of the constant jurisprudence supposed to be always productive.
“When a writing attributes defamation and insult to someone, the responsibility rests with the author of the article, the editor of the newspaper and the person to whom these accusations are attributed, if he does not issue a denial within a reasonable time: this is constant jurisprudence “, he explained.
“If, for example, someone accuses another of being a thief and the latter does not deny it, he is then confirming this accusation,” El Quessar added.
“In the case of Abdellah Bakkali: who is in a situation of silence means consent. If he was really acting in good faith and what he said before the judge is the strict reality, he would have issued this denial a very long time ago, namely after May 9, 2019, the date of the publication of the article,” he pointed out.
“Mr. Bakkali has been acquitted: It is neither fair, nor equitable, nor legal. We will appeal this judgment to ensure that it is overturned and amended,” said El Quessar.
The main thing is that by its verdict, the Court has indeed condemned and incriminated the comments reported in the May 9, 2019 edition of the daily “Assabah” and attributed to Abdellah Bakkali, comments considered as criminal and defamatory.
After this verdict at first instance, the Director General of MAP, Khalil Hachimi Idrissi, intends to appeal this court decision.
add your comment
Terms of publication : Not to offend the writer, people, sacred things, or attack religions or the divine self, and refrain from racist incitement and insults.