Semantics, at the heart of Russia, Kenya’s abstention from UNSC’s Western Sahara resolution

Semantics, at the heart of Russia, Kenya’s abstention from UNSC’s Western Sahara resolution
Thursday 27 October 2022 - 17:41

Put in blue despite Russia and Kenya’s amendment requests, today’s approved UN Security Council resolution on the Western Sahara contained a discernible change of tone compared to its predecessors, emphasizing the importance of involvement of all parties in the regional dispute. 

The resolution, which was presented by the United States as a pen holder and sponsor of the Moroccan autonomy proposal for the Western Sahara in the UN organ, was voted favorably by 13 members, with abstentions from both Russia and Kenya.

The final form of the resolution is “calling on the parties to demonstrate greater political will to achieve a solution, including through further consideration of their respective proposals and a renewed commitment to the UN-led effort with realism and a spirit of compromise, further encouraging neighboring countries to contribute to the political process and stressing the importance for all parties concerned to broaden their positions in order to advance a solution.”

The new resolution additionally brought new encouragement urging “all parties involved to build on the considerable progress made by the previous personal envoy” to pursue a resolution for the file, namely Morocco, polisario, Algeria and Mauritania.

Regarding the Tindouf refugee camps, the previous resolution saw the council “reiterating its request that the registration of refugees in the Tindouf camps be considered, and stressing that efforts should be made in this regard.” 

However, this security council is now “strongly urging” its demand for the registration of refugees in the camps, while for the first time, calling for the resumption of safe and regular resupply of Minurso team sites. 

This issue was recently raised in the Secretary-General’s report, as the polisario imposed movement restrictions on MINURSO after breaking the ceasefire in November 2020, which “severely limits the mission’s ability to resupply its team sites east of the wall.”

Reactions to the vote 

The permanent representative of the United States to the UN welcomed the Council’s support for Resolution 2654, expressing its “support for the efforts of the Special Envoy in the political process to settle the situation and ensure a lasting political solution.”

The US ambassador regretted the failure to achieve consensus on the UN resolution on the Western Sahara, stressing that the autonomy initiative represents a realistic and practical solution and a serious way to meet the aspirations of all parties involved in the dispute.

The US delegate declared his concern about the dire situation conditions reported in the Tindouf refugee camps, warning of the need to distribute aid in a transparent manner, and allow its arrival to beneficiaries in need.

The Russian representative in the Security Council for his part said that “Moscow abstained from voting on the draft resolution because the preparation of the document was not in a consultative manner, and our comments, which we referred to the states, were not interacted with or taken into consideration.”

The Russian delegate explained that “the final text is not balanced, and raises doubts about the impartiality of the United States in carrying out its responsibilities in the Council.”

The representative concluded saying: “The resolutions that renewed the work of MINURSO included decisions harmful to the neutral approach in the Sahara, and do not reflect the conditions on the ground, especially with regard to De Mistura’s efforts.”

Kenyan representative Martin Kimani, who abstained from voting in today’s council session, expressed his support for the MINURSO mission in the Western Sahara and the Special Envoy, noting that “this emerged in our support for the previous resolution 2602.”

The representative said that “the decision is far from the mandate and will not help in reaching a practical and realistic political solution,” noting that “the constructive proposals that we presented during the negotiations were not taken into account.”

“We are concerned about this decision, which does not reflect the commitment of the Security Council to one of its resolutions, which is to guarantee the right of self-determination for the Sahrawi people within the framework of arrangements in line with the principles of the United Nations and the role of the concerned parties,” he stated. 

The Kenyan diplomat explained that his country “affirms the right to self-determination by holding a referendum in the Sahara,” although the resolution pertaining to this form has long been forgone by the UN, for lack of feasible census protocol. 

Kenya seeks to enhance cooperation with Morocco and the Sahara, stressed the delegate, adding: “We understand the controversial nature of the situation, and we will exert our efforts to reach a just and consensual political solution, and urge the parties to respond to the recommendations of the Security Council.”

Omar Hilale, Morocco’s permanent representative to the United Nations said that Kenya’s reasons behind the abstention are lacking, considering the African country “voted in favor of the same resolution last year.”

add your comment

Terms of publication : Not to offend the writer, people, sacred things, or attack religions or the divine self, and refrain from racist incitement and insults.

Society
67 Moroccan migrants remain detained in Libya as families seek repatriation
Monday 16 November 2026 - 20:00

67 Moroccan migrants remain detained in Libya as families seek repatriation

International
Moroccans could lose Spanish citizenship under Vox proposal to review naturalizations
Monday 16 November 2026 - 18:00

Moroccans could lose Spanish citizenship under Vox proposal to review naturalizations

News
Morocco nears deal to buy French-made Scorpene submarines for Royal Navy
Monday 16 November 2026 - 15:56

Morocco nears deal to buy French-made Scorpene submarines for Royal Navy

Economy
Morocco's Tourist Overnight Stays Rise 7% to 34.8 Million by End-September 2026
Monday 16 November 2026 - 15:04

Morocco's Tourist Overnight Stays Rise 7% to 34.8 Million by End-September 2026