After a short deliberation process, a twelve-member jury convicted Minneapolis Police Officer Derek Chauvin Tuesday of three counts of murder and manslaughter.
Both the defense and prosecution rested their cases in the trial of the Officer Derek Chauvin for the murder of George Floyd after counsel delivered closing arguments, summing up the case for the jury, addressing what the evidence had shown and what conclusions the jury should reach.
Chauvin’s defense counsel had offered a flimsy defense focusing on Floyd’s preexisting heart condition, the presence of drugs in his bloodstream, and the fear Chauvin allegedly felt from a small crowd of bystanders with cell phones who were urging him to get off the Black man. While Chauvin did not testify, invoking his 5th Amendment right against self-incrimination, his defense lawyer argued that Chauvin’s alleged fear, including the prior 45 minutes before the nine minutes and 29 seconds he had his knee on Floyd’s neck, made the force that he used “reasonable.”
The prosecutor was far more effective in his closing argument. He said the case was so simple a child could understand it. “And a child did understand it,” he said, referring to the nine-year-old girl who recorded Floyd’s killing on her cell phone camera and who asked Chauvin to “get off him.”
The prosecution closed with a poignant juxtaposition: “You’ve heard that George Floyd’s heart was too big,” said the principal prosecutor in closing argument. “The truth of the matter is that George Floyd is dead because Officer Chauvin’s heart was too small.”
The case went to the jury Monday to deliberate and reach a verdict.
Speculation and hope abounded in the community, but many had doubts that Chauvin, who is white, would be convicted.
The jury returned its verdict Tuesday afternoon, convicting Chauvin on all three charges of second-degree murder, third-degree murder, and manslaughter.
When the verdict was about to be announced, people flooded the streets of Minneapolis including the very spot where Floyd was killed, in anticipation. When it was announced, people on the streets shouted “justice,” those in their cars honked their horns, and many waved Black Lives Matter flags.
Many told reporters that a weight had been lifted off their shoulders and that the country is going in the right direction.
Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota said about the protestors and demonstrators, “This is their day. This jury did the right thing.” But she warned that the Senate should not wait any longer to address issues of police violence.
“We have to pass police reform and ban chokeholds,” she said. “I hope my colleagues [in the US Senate] see this as a beginning and not an end.”
Van Jones, a prominent Black political analyst and lawyer, said after the verdict, this morning people were “scared to hope. That is what justice looks like.” But, he said, it is “just a start.”
Former federal prosecutor Joyce Vance said, “The jury system worked in this case, and it’s a defining moment for America.”
The Reverend Al Sharpton who is representing the Floyd family called the verdict “a monumental win,” however, he said it’s only one round. “It’s not over yet,” said the Reverend, “but God brought us through.”
Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison, who spoke on behalf of the prosecution team, said “We pursued justice wherever it led.” But he did not call today’s verdict “justice.”
“Justice implies true restoration,” he said. “This is accountability. That’s a first step toward justice.”
Ellison described the “bouquet of humanity” of bystanders—old, young, men, women, Black and white, a child going to buy a snack, and brave young women, teenagers who stopped and intervened. “Although they didn’t know Floyd, they stopped and raised their voices and even challenged authority because of Floyd’s humanity. Because they knew it was wrong. They did it again in this trial. Simple yet profound acts of courage,” he said.
Recognizing that emotions are running high, and in light of protests and riots that have already occurred, Ellison urged everyone to “honor the legacy of George Floyd” and to do that “calmly and peacefully.”
“This verdict reminds us how hard it is to make enduring change,” he said, listing more than a dozen more Black victims of law enforcement who have not had accountability or justice. “We can end racism if we decide now to have true liberty and justice for all,” said Ellison.
The verdict is so significant that President Biden spoke to the nation Tuesday evening. He acknowledged that the federal government must step up to “address systemic and institutional racism” and that the US Congress must act on the legislation Vice President Kamala Harris helped to write. “It should not take a year” to pass that legislation, he said.
“We have to change hearts and minds before justice will be done. That is the work we have to do in George Floyd’s memory,” said the President. “This can be a moment of significant change.”
Chauvin now faces up to 40 years in prison for second-degree murder, up to 25 years for third-degree murder, and up to 10 years for second-degree manslaughter. Immediately after the verdict, he was remanded into custody, pending sentencing which will occur in about eight weeks.
Whether the judge imposes the maximum sentence for each crime is unclear. But there is little doubt Chauvin will be in prison for a very long time.
add your comment
Terms of publication : Not to offend the writer, people, sacred things, or attack religions or the divine self, and refrain from racist incitement and insults.