The leader of Sahrawis for Peace, a movement that split from the Polisario Front, has sharply criticized UN envoy Staffan de Mistura for what he described as a “lack of courage” and “absence of a clear strategy” to revive negotiations on the Sahara dispute.
In a statement published on the group’s official Facebook page, Ahmad Barikalla, the movement’s first secretary, said the envoy “continues to call for creativity and engagement, yet dares not present concrete proposals or a clear roadmap.” He accused de Mistura of focusing too heavily on humanitarian warnings and regional instability rather than taking “bold political leadership.”
“After three years in office, the envoy still asks more questions than he provides answers, even about his own performance,” Barikalla said. “Instead of charting a direction or setting out a roadmap, he limits himself to posing questions to the Council and to the parties, as though his role were that of an observer rather than an active mediator.”
Barikalla also criticized de Mistura for failing to address the breakdown of the 1991 ceasefire between Morocco and the Polisario Front in 2020. “Hundreds of young Sahrawis have lost their lives since the collapse of the ceasefire, yet the Polisario still lacks a coherent vision of how its current military approach could lead to a positive political outcome,” he said.
He accused the UN envoy of showing a “worrying disconnect between the grim realities in Tindouf camps and the official rhetoric in the UN Security Council,” saying that de Mistura’s mediation has been marked by “a lack of innovation and real change.”
According to Barikalla, the envoy has failed to acknowledge emerging political shifts among Sahrawis themselves, notably the rise of Sahrawis for Peace, which he described as “neither the voice of Polisario, nor Algeria, nor Morocco,” but rather a movement calling for a “realistic political solution and rejecting military options.”
He added that de Mistura’s recent call to resume the roundtable talks before the end of the year “lacks any meaningful substance,” offering “no new ideas or alternatives to bridge differences.” Instead, he accused the envoy of seeking “another photo opportunity with delegations, like his predecessors James Baker and Horst Köhler, whose meetings produced no results.”
Barikalla concluded that if the mandates of both MINURSO and the UN envoy are renewed without major changes, “the United Nations will have, for the 35th time, wasted precious time and resources in the sands of the Sahara.”
Only a “fundamental review of the mandate and decisive leadership from influential powers, including the current U.S. administration,” he said, could prevent the Sahara from remaining “a glaring symbol of multilateral failure, with Sahrawis left hostage to frustration and nihilism.”
add your comment
Terms of publication : Not to offend the writer, people, sacred things, or attack religions or the divine self, and refrain from racist incitement and insults.