Former Israeli Ambassador to France Elie Barnavi and French historian Vincent Lemire on Tuesday urged French President Emmanuel Macron to impose immediate sanctions on Israel, citing what they described as a humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza.
In an op-ed published by Le Monde, Barnavi and Lemire called on Macron to take swift and decisive action. “Mr. President, if immediate sanctions are not imposed on Israel, you will be forced to acknowledge a graveyard,” they wrote. “Action must be taken now to ensure broad access to food and medical supplies in Gaza.”
They argued that only “concrete and immediate” sanctions could influence Israeli public opinion and, by extension, the Israeli government. “To end the famine, ensure a lasting ceasefire, secure the release of all hostages, protect Palestinians in the West Bank, and save Israel from itself, sanctions are essential,” they said.
The authors dismissed the justification of waiting for a European Union consensus, noting Macron’s July 24 pledge that France would recognize the State of Palestine at the United Nations General Assembly in September. That declaration, they said, has since gained support from countries such as the United Kingdom and Canada.
“France can and must lead a coalition of willing European nations,” Barnavi and Lemire urged. “You must act now. The situation is far too urgent to wait.” They also condemned the Israeli Knesset’s July 23 vote to support the annexation of the West Bank, passed by a margin of 71 to 13, as a dangerous escalation.
The op-ed also criticized what the authors described as a double standard in international policy. They noted that while the European Union has imposed 18 sanctions packages on Russia, it has yet to apply any measures against Israel.
Barnavi and Lemire argued that Israel’s geographic isolation would make any economic sanctions “effective and immediately noticeable in shops across the country.”
“Mr. President,” they warned, “do not mistake diplomatic noise for facts on the ground. Since your July 24 announcement, everything may have changed diplomatically, but nothing has changed in Gaza.” They concluded, “The promise of recognition does not fill empty stomachs.”
Elie Barnavi served as Israel’s ambassador to France from 2000 to 2002. Vincent Lemire is a historian at Paris-Est Gustave Eiffel University and previously directed the French Research Center in Jerusalem from 2019 to August 2023.
add your comment
Terms of publication : Not to offend the writer, people, sacred things, or attack religions or the divine self, and refrain from racist incitement and insults.