Supreme Court of Auditors unveils crippling dysfunctions in health sector

Supreme Court of Auditors unveils crippling dysfunctions in health sector
MAP
Wednesday 16 March 2022 - 18:33

The Supreme Court of Auditors underscored, in its general report for the years 2019 and 2020, several defects on the level of the Moroccan health sector.

The report noted structural unbalances related to the health system’s governance, guidance, and monitoring at the health sector level to the strategy of the Ministry of Health.

These deficiencies include a lack of financial resources necessary to accomplish all the tasks entrusted to the health sector and a lack of medical, paramedical, administrative, and technical human resources.

The report also underlined issues of proper infrastructure and equipment dedicated to the reception and the treatment of patients and providing quality care service.

It also brought to attention deficiencies in health centers’ organizational and operational levels and imbalances in the information system.

Lack of governance

Following monitoring the Ministry of Health’s governance and strategic planning process between 2010 and 2020, the Supreme Court of Auditors noted that essential governance bodies had not been established.

These instances concern the National Health Advisory Board and the National Treatment Submission Committee.

The above finding also applies to the most critical planning and programming mechanisms that have not been put into place, whose creation is provided by legislative and regulatory texts.

According to the report, “The tools that have been created remain insufficiently activated.”

Regarding the strategic planning process, the report noted the poor framing and documentation of the process, accentuated by the inability to develop accurate indicators to track the scope to which objectives have been achieved, by lack of summation of achievements, and by a lack of evaluation.

Regarding the issues mentioned above, the Court formulated several recommendations, beginning with the “Establishment of a governance body consistent with the national health system so that it is applicable.”

The Court also recommended activating “All governance bodies and tools to ensure the activation of the governance system as a whole.”

The establishment of governing bodies should be accompanied by “providing the evaluation of the effectiveness and efficiency of the governance system and its impact on the management of the health system in general and on its presentation treatments in particular.”

The report also noted that it is essential to improve the Ministry of Health’s strategic planning process by putting a proper framework covering all its stages, proper documentation of the process, and leadership, monitoring, and evaluation mechanisms.

A poor Health Information System

Following auditing the information programs of work processes within the Ministry, “the operation and use of practical information programs, and the management of significant information projects,” the Court indicated several constraints.

Although the Ministry of Health’s information system “contains 62 information applications distributed to the various health departments and facilities”, there has been little reporting of professional operations framed by “heterogeneous, incompatible, and poorly exploited software,” according to the same report.

Additionally, information project completion rates are meager, and information program planning does not sustain “integrated monitoring” with a “poor framing level of Information systems.” The report also indicated an inability to manage projects.

Given “The weak current infrastructure that does not match the growing needs of the department, which negatively affects the optimal functioning of programs,” according to the Court, “gaps in the use and operation of information programs” heightened by “insufficient and inadequate infrastructure” impede the development of information programs.

Recommendations of the Court to improve the health information system and its programming included ensuring that “The Ministry’s most important professional operations are covered by appropriate information programs that are consistent with the reformative directions and development of the health sector.”

The report also called, among other recommendations, for “ensuring that this coverage is consistent with generally accepted good practice regarding health sector information technology, including consistency and compatibility.”

Constrains for hospital construction and equipment projects

Following the Council monitoring of the progress of hospital construction and capital projects to measure the planning process programming and implementation of hospital construction and equipment projects, the report also noted several structural deficiencies.

The document points out the absence of the health map as stipulated by law N° 09.3, marked by differing implications of investment options on hospital performance indicators.

Concerning Medical programming, technical and functional programming, the report emphasized that the Data Matrix requires improvement in the light of gaps in production standards, with the absence of “benchmarks that define, for each hospital reference level, the requirements for the spatial organization, management, and equipment of technical platforms.”

The Court stated the importance of “Ensuring compliance with technical and functional programming” with the need to consider the adequacy of equipment and buildings, alongside steering and management of hospital investment projects.

The report also recommended “completing the elaboration of the health map provided for by law N° 34-09 and ensuring its approval and adoption” to exploit and manage hospital assets,

The Court also emphasized developing the mechanisms and programs of medical and technical programming, providing modernized hospital facilities with the necessary tools to execute their missions, and providing “The health services they need for this purpose.”

As part of its evaluation activities, the Court spotted deficiencies and unbalances within the medical emergency systems, dissatisfaction with the National Tuberculosis Control Program, and highlighted some issues regarding the National Blood Transfusion System.

Responding to the Supreme Court of Auditors’ findings and recommendations, the Minister of Health and Social Protection stated that concerning the governance bodies, “Two regional health observatories were able to prepare regional reports.”

The minister explains in this regard that this “Does not mean that the rest of the observatories are not functioning, but rather all the regional observatories are operational and carry out their tasks related to data collection and monitoring of health indicators at the regional level.”

For strategic planning, the minister argued, “The development of plans and strategies is prepared based on the diagnosis and analysis of a set of health and demographic data
and social and economic data”.

As indicated in the report, the minister continued to tackle and respond to the different findings and remarks of the Court.

The report for the years 2019 and 2020, following the royal directives, ensures that the Supreme Council of Auditors fulfills its constitutional prerogatives of evaluation and control under chapter 148 of the Constitution of the Kingdom.

add your comment

Terms of publication : Not to offend the writer, people, sacred things, or attack religions or the divine self, and refrain from racist incitement and insults.

News
Morocco installs early warning system in Ourika to protect residents from flash floods
Monday 16 November 2026 - 10:27

Morocco installs early warning system in Ourika to protect residents from flash floods

Society
Morocco ranks sixth among main sources of new migrants to OECD countries in 2024
Sunday 15 November 2026 - 23:00

Morocco ranks sixth among main sources of new migrants to OECD countries in 2024

Economy
Lekjaa defends FIFA tax exemptions ahead of 2030 World Cup, rejects opposition proposals
Sunday 15 November 2026 - 21:00

Lekjaa defends FIFA tax exemptions ahead of 2030 World Cup, rejects opposition proposals

News
Morocco-France submarine talks with naval group reach advanced stage, French report says
Sunday 15 November 2026 - 20:16

Morocco-France submarine talks with naval group reach advanced stage, French report says