Comments by Moroccan researcher Ahmed Assid linking the Fajr prayer to rural life have triggered strong reactions, with critics arguing that “urban life has not changed this obligation” and warning against “projection readings” that, they said, distort Islamic rites rooted in fixed devotional texts, according to statements received by Hespress.
Assid wrote that advocacy for Fajr prayer is “among the manifestations of the misery of contemporary Islamic consciousness,” arguing that religious texts have contexts and that changes in time, place and lifestyle “inevitably” change believers’ religious behaviour. He said that after electricity, television, nightlife, public sector work patterns and mobile phones, sleep now comes “on average, after midnight for the overwhelming majority.”
Assid said it is “laughable” that those promoting Fajr prayer “are still in front of their phone screens at 1 a.m.,” adding they are calling for something “they themselves will not be able to do.”
He also described urging people to pray as “a form of guardianship over others’ lives,” saying prayer is “a personal individual choice” tied to “the vertical relationship between the individual and God.”
In responses carried by Hespress, critics said that despite faster urban rhythms, night lighting and shifting work and sleep schedules, the city “did not eliminate the centrality of Fajr in the lives of Muslims,” adding that many still perform it on time as a spiritual practice beyond “temporal suitability” or “physical comfort,” and arguing that “religion is a fixed system transcending history.”
Idriss El Ganbouri, a researcher in Islamic history and thought, said attempts to detach Fajr prayer from current social context show “a clear dysfunction” in understanding Moroccan society, adding that field realities point to “the continuing religious presence” and “increasing turnout for Fajr prayer, especially in major cities.”
He said a simple visit to mosques in Rabat or Sale at dawn shows large numbers of youth in the front rows, unlike the 1980s when older worshippers dominated.
Assid, in separate remarks to Hespress, defended his view that traditional early sleep made waking at dawn consistent with lived reality, and said calls to wake for Fajr through “emotional preaching” without a realistic reading of modern constraints remain “empty calls” that cannot be achieved on the ground, citing cases where an imam attends while most people stay away.
add your comment
Terms of publication : Not to offend the writer, people, sacred things, or attack religions or the divine self, and refrain from racist incitement and insults.